The Barrymore Trilogy Blogathon: The Beloved Rogue (dir. Alan Crosland, 1927)


This submission is for the Barrymore Trilogy Blogathon hosted at In the Good Old Days of Classic Hollywood. Check out the site for most Barrymore-themed posts!

While he had a prolific stage career and starred in more than a few sound pictures, I have always associated John Barrymore with silent film. His turn as the tormented Dr. Jekyll and the lecherous Mr. Hyde is his most famous performance in this medium, but Barrymore also dabbled in his fair share of escapist historical flicks, such as Beau Brummel and Don Juan. But my favorite of the lot has to be The Beloved Rogue, a masterpiece of ham and swashbuckling.

Doctor macro image of john barrymore

Villon once he cleans up during act two.

Barrymore plays Francois Villon, a thirteenth century French poet who also specializes in lovemaking, partying, and general mayhem. However, his prankster nature gets him in trouble with the erratic Louis XI (Conrad Veidt in his campy-licious American film debut) and the treacherous Duke of Burgundy (Lawson Butt), the former of which proceeds to banish Francois from his beloved Paris for undermining royal authority. Francois gets over his heartbreak quickly and starts plotting to get back at the king and his cronies, whilst also falling in love with the beautiful Charlotte de Vauxcelles (Marceline Day), an ardent fan of his poetry. His desire for revenge and Charlotte intersect when the unwilling young woman is betrothed to Burgundy himself.

The Beloved Rogue is a lark, offering the best of old-school Hollywood escapism: the swashbuckling action, good humor, fun characters, and romance under the starlight. In the traditional MGM fashion, the production values are sublime. Essentially, all the good stuff in pure, unfiltered form. The supporting cast is fabulous all around. The lovely Marceline Day makes a good contrast to Barrymore’s intense energy with her character’s reserved nature. Or maybe that’s just me being nice about her rather wooden acting. At any rate, her performance is inoffensive and she’s lovely to look at in her grand costumes. Mack Swain and Slim Summerville are great fun as Barrymore’s clownish lackeys. And then there’s Conrad Veidt, who plays the creepy Louis XI, a character whose danger to Francois ebbs and flows with his paranoia and good humor.

But of course, the one who steals the show is Barrymore himself. Ah the ham that is this performance, the delightful ham! As Villon, he leaps through Paris with the gusto of Douglas Fairbanks. He’s unafraid to troll anyone, including the king, and generally acts like an imp. That is, until he shares the frame with Marceline Day. I do confess that I wish his character had retained his sense of mischief when courting his lady love; he changes on a dime to an ardent wooer once the two are alone together. Ah well, it’s John Barrymore in his prime doing love scenes—who am I to complain?

Villon and pals party hard.

Villon and pals party hard.

The only flaw of the picture would be the climax, which features Barrymore being tortured in a manner more befitting a drama than a swashbuckler. It’s unpleasant and ruins the fun. But otherwise, The Beloved Rogue is awesome, an example of Hollywood excess done right and Barrymore ham cooked to perfection.

11 thoughts on “The Barrymore Trilogy Blogathon: The Beloved Rogue (dir. Alan Crosland, 1927)

  1. Pingback: THE BARRYMORE TRILOGY BLOGATHON HAS NOW ARRIVED | In The Good Old Days Of Classic Hollywood.

  2. I lov John’s silents! And whenever he is in love scenes, my heart mlts a little…
    I haveen’t seen The Beloved Rogue, but it may be very interesting. Well, I can’t say no to a silent film!
    Don’t forget to read my contribution to the blogathon! 🙂



  4. Thanks so much for participating in the blogathon. I’ve only just got around to reading the entries now, and yours was highly worth the wait. Excellent post. I’ve always loved this movie.

    I’ve also just announced a new blogathon that I would like to invite you to participate in. The link is below with more details


    • I know, does it not? The Beloved Rogue, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, and Don Juan are all fun silent John Barrymore excursions. Lionel Barrymore played a great deal of villains during the period; he’s excellent in West of Zanzibar and the otherwise awful revolutionary war epic, America.


  5. John Barrymore is fantastic in this – I love all the swashbuckling, but there are also more poignant moments like the scene where he takes his clown make-up off. Loved your post – and what a great poster at the start.


  6. Hi. I just thought I would drop by to let you know that I’ve just announced the Second Annual Barrymore Trilogy Blogathon for August. I’m currently going through last years roster and letting folks know that it’s on again. I would love to invite you to participate once again. The link is below with more details.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s